Rails

July 2023: Inspector’s Corner

Tuesday, August 1st, 2023

Introduction

There are times during inspections that I find some interesting cases of either violations to the ADA/TAS or some innovation in design that I sometimes share with my clients for them to learn for future projects.

Below are some examples:

But it is only finishes……

If you read my last newsletter (June: Alterations vs. Maintenance) I explained about alterations as defined by the ADA Standards as well as TAS. One of the still misunderstood projects that is considered alterations are flooring changes. The definition of alteration includes “re-surfacing of circulation paths”. A circulation path would include any flooring or ground surface where people walk or use their mobility devices on.

Alteration: A change to a building or facility that affects or could affect the usability of the building or facility or portion thereof. Alterations include, but are not limited to, remodeling, renovation, rehabilitation, reconstruction, historic restoration, resurfacing of circulation paths or vehicular ways,

changes or rearrangement of the structural parts or elements, and changes or rearrangement in the plan configuration of walls and full-height partitions.

Flooring changes, even if it is replacing a floor finish with the SAME floor finish (carpet with carpet) will be considered an alteration and the ADA standards and the TAS will have to be applied. So what sections would apply?

Section 302 which requires firm, stable and slip resistant flooring. No openings greater than 1/2″.

Section 303 no changes in level greater than 1/4″ without a bevel, 1/2″ with a bevel or ramp when greater than 1/2″

And if the flooring occurs in areas that are considered a primary function, it will also trigger compliance with section 202.4


Installing new flooring will be considered an alteration.

 

 

Replacing one or two damaged carpet tile would be considered maintenance. Replacing an entire carpet would be an alteration.

Handrail extensions

When you have a ramp along an accessible route (that is not a curb ramp), and if the ramp has a height of 6″ or more, then handrails on both sides of the ramp will have to be provided. And at the end of the ramp run, if the handrail is not continous, they must extend 12″ at the top and bottom of the ramp runs. And that extension must be

505.10 Handrail Extensions. Handrail gripping surfaces shall extend beyond and in the same direction of stair flights and ramp runs in accordance with 505.10.

505.10.1 Top and Bottom Extension at Ramps. Ramp handrails shall extend horizontally above the landing for 12 inches (305 mm) minimum beyond the top and bottom of ramp runs. Extensions shall return to a wall, guard, or the landing surface, or shall be continuous to the handrail of an adjacent ramp run.

 


This figure shows the handrail extension that extends horizontally above the landing and returns to the post.

At several inspections recently, I have encountered handrails that rather than extending 12″ horizontally in the same direction of the ramp run beyond the top or bottom of the ramp run, they eiither turn 90 degrees, or don’t fully extend.

This photo above shows a handrail that did not extend 12″ beyond the bottom of the ramp run


The handrail in the photo above did not extend 12″ in the same direction as the ramp run, but rather it turns 90 degrees which is not an extension and it is not allowed (unless the ramp was existing per excepton listed below)

There are a few exceptions for when handrails do not have to extend:

EXCEPTIONS:

1. Extensions shall not be required for continuous handrails at the inside turn of switchback or dogleg stairs and ramps.

2. In assembly areas, extensions shall not be required for ramp handrails in aisles serving seating where the handrails are discontinuous to provide access to seating and to permit crossovers within aisles.

3. In alterations, full extensions of handrails shall not be required where such extensions would be hazardous due to plan configuration.

Ramps and Curb Ramps

Wednesday, September 20th, 2017

ADA Section 405 Ramps and 406 Curb Ramps

We all know that one of the ways that people in wheelchairs maneuver between changes in level greater than 1/2″ is by using a ramp. When an accessible route crosses a curb, it requires a “curb ramp”. There is confusion between requirements for ramps vs. curb ramps. Let’s see if we can make it more clear:

1. The first thing to remember is that curb ramps are also ramps. The main difference is that a “curb ramp” is located at a curb and a “ramp” is located elsewhere (like along the route to the front door, or on the interior of the building)

The curb ramp is the one that crossed a curb at the parking spaces. The ramp in the background is part of the entry and does not cross the curb

 

2. Both ramps and curb ramps require a maximum running slope of 1:12 and a maximum cross slope of 1:48 (per 405.2 and 405.3)

Cross slope

running slope

 

3. Both ramps and curb ramps require that the surface be stable, firm and slip resistant and should not have changes in level at ramp runs. (per 405.4)

 

4. Both ramps and curb ramps require a minimum clear width of 36″ (per 405.5). The width is measured inside the handrails if they are provided.

 

5. and Both ramps and curb ramps and their landings require that they do not accumulate water. (per section 405.10)

 

The curb ramp shows water accumulated

The curb ramp shows water accumulated

Those are the only requirements that they share. There are other requirements that only apply to Ramps and some that only apply to Curb Ramps.

ADA Section 405 Ramps

Besides all the items listed above, ramps have other requirements.  These requirements only apply to ramps and NOT to curb ramps:
1. Only a ramp cannot have a vertical rise greater than 30″ without a landing.  In other words, if a ramp rises more than 30″ it must have a landing before the next run begins (per section 405.6)
2. Only a  ramp requires flat landing at the top and bottom of the ramp run (per section 405.7).  Flat can be no steeper than 1:48 that is 60″ deep and the width of the ramp (like the figure shown above).  Only a ramp requires a 60″x60″ landing when it changes direction
 
3) Only a ramp ramp requires handrails on both sides (except if the rise is less than 6″).
4) Only a ramp requires edge protection if there is a drop off on either side of the ramp. So even if a curb ramp is higher than 6″ in vertical rise, it will not require handrails.

ADA Section 406 Curb Ramps

Curb ramps have the following unique requirements that regular ramps do not require:
1. Only a curb ramp requires that the bottom of the ramp have a slope no steeper than 1:20.  This is called a counter slope.  (Per section 406.2).  A regular ramp will require a landing at the bottom with a slope no steeper than 1:48 in all directions.
2. Only a curb ramp requires its side have flares if located along a walkway.  The flared sides are not required, but if they are provided they must comply with section 406.3
Flare sides are recommended if the curb ramp is located within a path of travel. This would prevent any tripping.  Since the flared sides are not “required” a parallel curb ramp is allowed to be used.

 

this curb ramp is parallel with the curb and no flares are required

3. Only a curb ramp requires a 36″ deep landing at the top.  The slope of that landing is not specified and it would depend on where is it located.  For example, if the curb ramp terminates at a sidewalk that is parallel to the ramp, then the slope could be as steep as 1:20 (5%).  But if it is located so that the ramp and the walkway are perpendicular, then the landing must not have a slope steeper than 1:48 since it will also be part of the cross slope of the sidewalk. (per 406.4)
4. Curb ramps and the flared sides cannot project onto a vehicular way or parking spaces and access aisles. (per section 406.5)

this curb ramp did not require the flared sides_ and the one_s provided project onto the vehicular way

5.  A diagonal curb ramp will require a counter close 48″ in length and located outside of the traffic area (per section 406.6)
6. When curb ramps are located in a traffic island or median, then the landing must not interfere with another curb ramp.  A 48″ space along the direction of travel must also be provided (per section 406.7)

Curb Ramps at Public Rights of Way

 If you are wondering why we haven’t mentioned detectable warnings (i.e. contrasting color and texture/truncated domes), it is because curb ramps do not require them anymore.  Some Departments of Transportation in different States have adopted a Public Right of Way Guidelines that give us a scoping for when the detectable warnings are required.
Basically any curb ramp located inside the property line will not require detectable warnings.
Any curb ramp that is located in the public right of way will require a portion of the ramp to have detectable warnings.  The bottom 24″ of the curb ramp must have the truncated domes and the contrasting color.
Check your municipality on what they have adopted to see if their curb ramps need it.

Helping Houston

Abadi Accessibility will be donating 5% of the fees received in the month of September to help the victims of hurricaine Harvey.  Thank you for your assistance!
 
Need Barrier Free CEUs?
 
September 18-  TAID Day of Education: “Common mistakes in the Texas Accessibility Standards” at the Dallas Market Center
Save the dates: October 24 and 25th- “Barrier Free Design Room by Room” 2 hr Barrier Free HSW class at Inspire! 2017, Dallas Texas
Online courses:
Green CE On Demand webinar “How Accessible is Your work place?”
Green CE On Demand webinar “ADA and Residential Facilities”
or
If you are interested in Building Code seminars check out my colleague Shahla Layendecker with SSTL Codes
If you want to learn more about these standards, be sure to check out my books:
book cover
If you have any questions about these or any other topics, please feel free to contact me anytime.
Marcela Abadi Rhoads, FAIA RAS #240
Abadi Accessibility
214. 403.8714

Inspector’s Corner

Wednesday, June 1st, 2016

The Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation requires that commercial projects that are over $50,000 in construction cost get a third party plan review as well as inspection.  During inspections I often see violations that tend to occur more often than others.  In this newsletter you will find three examples of items that happen often enough where I think it would be important to bring it to your attention.  Hope this prevents these violations to happen to you.

Door Hardware

Herculite doors are very popular in office buildings.  The door hardware varies in location and size.  Some of the hardware that we see are vertical handles that will sometimes reach the floor.
c224c229-2afb-4e7e-8954-a17a4f7fd09f
This door has vertical handle that almost reaches the ground.
The 2010 ADA and the 2012 TAS require that the bottom surface of swing doors have smooth surfaces up to 10″ a.f.f.  on the push side.
404.2.10 Door and Gate Surfaces. Swinging door and gate surfaces within 10 inches (255 mm) of the finish floor or ground measured vertically shall have a smooth surface on the push side extending the full width of the door or gate. Parts creating horizontal or vertical joints in these surfaces shall be within 1/16 inch (1.6 mm) of the same plane as the other. Cavities created by added kick plates shall be capped.
When the door hardware extends to the ground, or below 10″ a.f.f.,  the door would not have a smooth surface.
c93fd4f7-a8ac-4d33-a1b5-92b081db3e47

Shell building finish out

When I inspect empty shell buildings at strip shopping centers or office parks, I inspect elements that are new and installed.  Since there are no tenants at the point of the inspection, the entry door that is provided is only inspected for slopes and heights at threshold.  The location of the parking spaces in relation to the doors that are provided is also inspected, since the ADA and TAS require that the accessible parking space is located at the shortest distance to the door.
 
208.3.1 General. Parking spaces complying with 502 that serve a particular building or facility shall be located on the shortest accessible route from parking to an entrance complying with 206.4. Where parking serves more than one accessible entrance,parking spaces complying with 502 shall be dispersed and located on the shortest accessible route to the accessible entrances.
cdfc8910-6a4f-4728-a08a-9e8972943b90
In this shell building the accessible parking spaces are located at the shortest accessible route to just one door.  Since there are several entrances, the parking spaces should be dispersed.
As tenants move in and new doors are added, parking spaces may be in violation of the proximity to the entry. Every time a new tenant moves in and alters his space, the inspection will include the existing parking that might have already been inspected during the shell building inspection.  The existing parking might be a violation to an already inspected building if the location is not the shortest route to the entry.
eba0f877-2b81-463b-ad61-cb9c06837c30
The accessible parking space in this shopping center is located in front of one tenant space.  There are other doors which imply that new tenants will move in and therefore the parking for those will be in violation.

Handrail extensions

Many times I see new ramps get built into existing sites.  ADA and TAS require that ramp handrails extend 12″ on the top and bottom of the ramp.
505.10 Handrail Extensions. Handrail gripping surfaces shall extend beyond and in the same direction of stair flights and ramp runs in accordance with 505.10.
EXCEPTIONS: 1. Extensions shall not be required for continuous handrails at the inside turn of switchback or dogleg stairs and ramps.
2. In assembly areas, extensions shall not be required for ramp handrails in aisles serving seating where the handrails are discontinuous to provide access to seating and to permit crossovers within aisles.
 
3. In alterations, full extensions of handrails shall not be required where such extensions would be hazardous due to plan configuration
 
Many times the handrail extension is not done correctly.  I typically see them turning the corner.
1da1250e-33ba-46eb-b2dc-9315d7af8f57
This ramp handrail does not extend 12″ beyond the ramp run, but instead it turns to avoid projecting into the existing sidewalk. Because this is a new ramp, during design there would have been an opportunity to give enough room for the ramp handrail extension.
6d304666-f032-47d2-a7f0-713a482689e8
As you can see in this picture, there is a level on the sidewalk.  This indicates a slope which is part of the ramp.  The handrails were not extended all the way to the end of the ramp run on this ramp.
972f7c66-1d7f-470c-a7a7-e750eafaa961
The hand rail extension is located just shy of the end of the ramp run in this ramp.

Need CEUs

Green CE live Webinar June 7th 12:00 p.m. “Applying the ADA on Existing Buildings”
If you are interested in Building Code seminars check out my colleague Shahla Layendecker with SSTL Codes
If you want to learn more about these standards, be sure to check out my books:

97c8a80a-9426-4c3d-88fb-ef6213d94712
6fc8cab3-4989-476b-b86b-d65fdc8c74cc

They are available for sale now. (also available as an e-book)

If you have any questions about these or any other topics, please feel free to contact me anytime.

Marcela Abadi Rhoads, RAS #240
Abadi Accessibility
214. 403.8714
marhoads@abadiaccess.com
www.abadiaccess.com

Accessible Playgrounds

Tuesday, March 1st, 2016
Before the 2010 ADA Standars were adopted, children with disabilities didn’t have provisions and requirements for access. One of the items that were included in the ADA Standards as of 2012 were playgrounds and play areas. The playground equipment themselves have to be accessible for children. There are requirements for access on the following items:
  1. Ground level play components: A playground equipment that is accessed from the grounds.  Some examples of ground level play components are  spring rockers, swings and diggers
  2. Elevated play components: A playground equipment that is accessed above the grounds. Some examples of elevated play components are slides and monkey bars.
  3. the accessible route: An uninterrupted path of travel that connects the entry and exit of play components.  A 60″ wide accessible route must be provided.  The running slope should be no steeper than 1:16 and the cross slope no steeper than 1:48.
  4. Use zones: The ground level area beneath and immediately adjacent to a play structure or play equipment that is used for  circulation around the play equipment and where it is predicted that a user would land when falling from or exiting the play equipment.
6a51a55d-dd25-461d-b7be-7eb6bba1aef5

Play components

The number of play components that must be on an accessible route is determined by how many “elevated components” are provided.  There is a table in the ADA that we use to determine that number. But a minimum of one of each type of ground level component should be provided.

84505de4-9591-40ec-b70f-8f2d78b8e65e

15f9c057-6f83-4180-912a-971a1f8d439c

This table sand box is considered a ground level play component and will require knee and toe clearances for children with wheelchairs to have access

f780492b-17c1-40f3-b6b5-bb87ddacbdce

Activity Centers are an example of ground level play component.  An accessible route should be provided at the entry and exit.  In addition a turning space inside the component and elements within children’s reach ranges should also be provided

a3ccbe80-7e8f-47ac-9017-456d9653909e

Swing sets are also ground level play components.  This picture shows a ground surface that is more stable, but wood chips are also acceptable.

For elevated play components 50% must have either a ramp or a transfer system to access them and be on an accessible route.  Ramp runs should have a running slope no steeper than 1:16 and the rise of any ramp shall be no more than 12″ and, where required, handrails must also be provided.  Handrails at these ramps do not require an extension at the top and bottom.

d231b62a-b1b8-492e-af0e-280d8df3fd27

This ramp connects elevated play components. The handrail provided must be between 20″-28″ a.f.f.

62b034cb-8946-4389-9c82-773c9d20991b

This photo shows both a platform on one side and a transfer step on the other

3634f952-1c25-431c-b47f-430a57e01454

A transfer platform should be between 11″-18″ a.f.f. and should have a clear floor space that is 48″ long centered on the platform

bcb27c9d-9945-4062-a475-7480b14dc375

Children with mobility issues will use their upper body to climb the steps once they reach the platform

Besides the accessible route and play components, use zones must be provided adjacent or below the playground equipment.  They should have a ground surface that complies with ASTM F1292 (1999 or 2004 edition).

9ec8ab54-81eb-4877-a00e-236964457d7b

ddcd8afc-07a2-4647-9441-0c9d4ce5229a

This playground shows the ground surface that complies with ASTM 1292

Interior play areas and soft contained play structures

The play structures and play areas that are located in restaurants and shopping centers must also be accessible.  Accessible routes connecting the different play components must be provided.  A transfer system is the most common means of access.

b6154f29-83d1-49ad-afe2-50c96cbcfebe

20d7bc35-ddff-4be3-900c-2509860ad321

This play structure does not have the required transfer system.  A child with disabilities would not be able to enter the structure.

656bc54b-08d8-4919-a414-941a667721c5

The play components in this play area are considered ground level components and only require an accessible route to the entrance and exit of the component.  If there are any operable elements, they should be within reach range.

Need CEUs

If you are interested in Building Code seminars check out my colleague Shahla Layendecker with SSTL Codes
If you want to learn more about these standards, be sure to check out my books:
97c8a80a-9426-4c3d-88fb-ef6213d94712

6fc8cab3-4989-476b-b86b-d65fdc8c74cc

If you have any questions about these or any other topics, please feel free to contact me anytime.

Marcela Abadi Rhoads, RAS #240
Abadi Accessibility
214. 403.8714
marhoads@abadiaccess.com
www.abadiaccess.com

Accessible Means of Egress

Wednesday, April 1st, 2015

The 1991 ADAAG required that all exits that served as a means of egress as defined in the IBC be accessible. the 2010 ADA Standards no longer scopes how many means of egress must be accessible,  but it refers to the 2003 IBC edition or 2000 IBC edition with 2001 supplement for the accessible means of egress requirements.  Typically, the IBC requires, if there is  one means of egress it must be accessible.  If there are two or more means of egress, then two accessible means of egress are required.

Although the ADA Standards do not have specific requirements for accessible means of egress, it references the IBC and adopts their requirements. This newsletter will explain where the IBC ends and the ADA begins when determining the means of egress requirements.

Accessible Means of Egress

An accessible means of egress, according to the IBC, is a “continuous and unobstructed way of egress travel from any point in a building or facility that provides an accessible route to an area of refuge, a horizontal exit, or a public way.

Exit access is any path from any location in a building to an exit.  Although we must follow what the IBC dictates on the means of egress requirements, an exit access in the ADA cannot be less than 36″ wide.  The IBC typically requires it to be wider (48″ min).

Exits include doors to the outside, enclosed exit stairways or horizontal exits.  The ADA requires that doors used to pass through a space to the exit meet the guidelines of section 404.  Those guidelines require maneuvering clearances, door hardware, opening force and closing speed to comply.  Means of egress doors could include doors into exit stairwell, doors leading to exterior exits or doors leading to exit corridors just to name a few.

af759776-8469-4ba9-8a47-7da0bdf5a132

cbdd1ee2-5ef9-413f-96ff-53bf846ec567

This exit door had a push side approach with both a closer and a latch.  The maneuvering was a forward approach, and the door was recessed more than 8″, therefore it required a 12″ additional space on the latch side (even though it was a means of egress door).   

An exit discharge is the path from an exit to a public way (i.e. street or alley).  The ADA does not have guidelines directly relating to an exit discharge.  Exit discharged are scoped by reference.  Assisted rescue including area of refuge are not scoped in the ADA, but may be in the IBC depending on whether the building is sprinklered or not.

Means of Egress Stairs

If there are any new stairs on the exterior or interior that are part of the means of egress, they must follow the guidelines on section 504 and 505.

Whereas the IBC will focus on the number of stairs required, including the width etc, the ADA focuses on the walking surface inclusing the depth of threads and height of risers, and whether the stair treads have nosings.  The ADA will also give guidelines on the handrails heights, size, shape and continuity.

cbadf55b-9cbd-458b-90c3-d0a236831883

Existing stairs are excempted

Signage

The ADA section 216.4 sets guidelines for exit doors, area of refuge, and directional signs that provide directions to accessible means of egress.  These signs must not only comply with the ADA sections 703 but also the IBC sections specified in the Standards.

68764719-24b3-44c1-b1cf-a8e07e86a933

Means of egress signs should have raised characters and visual characters with a certain size, depth, case, style and proportions all found in ADA section 703.2 and 703.5 If the visual characters are accompanied by braille that complies with ADA 703.3, then the visual characters provided do not have to have a specific case, style, height, proportions, height, or spacing.

050b78df-c50d-46a2-82c7-c0ee7cf77d9d

Upcoming Continuing Education Opportunities

“How Accessible is Your Work Place” By Green CE online Webinar- April 16th 3 p.m. CST

We will be presenting at the 2015 National AIA convention in Atlanta.  Our class will be “Applying the ADA in Existing and altered facilities: TH118 on May 14th

If you are interested in getting a Barrier Free/ADA CEU online, I partnered with Green CE.  We will be presenting live webinars this year.  We will post details as they become available

If you are interested in Building Code seminars check out my colleague Shahla Layendecker with SSTL Codes

If you want to learn more about these standards, be sure to check out my books:

“The ADA Companion Guide”  “Applying the ADA” published by Wiley. 

 

f6d0d3fd-b4dd-4507-a88a-ac46f993f5fb
6fc8cab3-4989-476b-b86b-d65fdc8c74cc

 They are available for sale now. (also available as an e-book)
If you have any questions about these or any other topics, please feel free to contact me anytime.

Marcela Abadi Rhoads, RAS #240
Abadi Accessibility
214. 403.8714
marhoads@abadiaccess.com
www.abadiaccess.com
Useful Links

 

4211966d-1763-427b-b22d-635a5a5536d8
23e5e0af-7846-472b-b702-19386acb4fca0e98de4a-47d4-412d-9302-b0212a4b2b0d

Accessible Airports

Wednesday, September 24th, 2014

Americans love to travel.  Travelling gives us the freedom to go to different destinations and experience different places.  People with disabilities also travel, and as such, the airports must be accessible.  For designers and airport operators, it is sometimes confusing what accessibility guidelines should be followed.

Under Part 382 of the Air Carrier Access Act (ACAA), air carriers are responsible for airport facilities or services that they “own, lease, operate, or otherwise control. The facilities, according the ACAA should follow the ADA Title III in those areas that are considered public accommodations and commercial areas.

Although the ADA’s statutory language exempts transportation “by aircraft:, airport terminals owned and operated by government entities are covered by Title II of the ADA which requires that the services are made available, and airport terminals open to the public are “public accommodation” covered by Title III of the ADA which requires building access. Both are subject to ADA access requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act Accessibility Guidelines (ADAAG).

Additionally, airports that receive federal financial assistance are subject to Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act. According to the U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT), “in order to be in compliance with Section 504, recipients must also be in compliance with all applicable regulations under the ADA.”

This newsletter will try to explain what those regulations.

Ticket Counters and Information Desks

Ticket counters and information desks outside the secured area fall under the ADA section 904 and possibly 902 since they are a public accommodation.  Section 904 discusses service and sales counters.  If the ticket counters are used for selling tickets or to provide some type of service, such as information, getting boarding passes, or checking in bags, those counters will require that a portion of the public side of the counter be no higher than 36″ a.f.f., and no shorter than 36″ in length.  A parallel or forward approach is allowed.

3911d12f-62cb-458f-b5c4-feef1d584e64

This ticket counter does not have a portion at 36″ a.f.f. , although the area where the baggage is turned in is open and lower.  It could be argued that the entire counter is part of the work area for the ticket agent, but in reality it is also where a customer approaches the ticket counter to receive their boarding pass or baggage claim stubs. This is not a compliant service counter.

55872bd4-d2a5-4536-99ba-a82bd02c2857

This ticket counter has a shallow counter that is at 36″ a.f.f. which was allowed by the 1991 ADAAG and it is a safe harbor, but a person with disabilities will have difficulty communicating with the ticket agent since the ticket counter is higher than 36″ a.f.f.

More and more you find that self service check in are being offered.  A passenger will not approach a ticket counter but a self service kiosk.  These should be within reach range per section 308 of the ADA.  There are other requirements that these might need for people that are visually impaired.

04b5ffaf-d8a2-4628-8c2f-53a2aef7da3d

Self-service kiosk systems clearly fall within the ACAA encompassing language, which incorporates the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Title III standard for accessible design.  This means that these kiosks should meet the reach ranges specified by the ADA but in addition it should have similar privacy requirements as the ATMs do. The kiosks should have the ability to communicate with the visually impaired as well s the hearing impaired patrons.  This is not yet happening, but the industry is aware of the deficiency and will hopefully act on that in the near future.

54a88289-1c5c-49af-9082-e3c15fa469f5

In the same area as the ticket counter there might be counters for filling out baggage tags.  These would fall under the ADA Section 902.  5% of the counters must be accessible and have a forward approach.  They should be no higher than 34″ a.f.f and they should have a knee space complying with ADA section 306

b568746f-1ae2-4cc8-8561-532b70a12b58

Other areas of the airport might have information counters.  Those will fall under the service counters of ADA Section 904.  They should also have a portion at 36″ a.f.f. so that a passenger can communicate with the person behind the counter.  According to 904.4 the accessible portion of the counter top shall extend the same depth as the sales or service counter top.  Therefore a separate counter attached to the front of the service counter may not be used.

65a29681-54cd-470a-a638-2b708eb2bdb7

Car rental counters are also considered a service counter and are required to be accessible and follow ADA Standards section 904

69a5737d-6aaa-4918-b264-8544200b9cd7

Terminal Gates

Once a passenger passes through security and is at their gate, the counters at the gate are also required to follow ADA section 904.  The counter shown on the picture below followed the 1991 ADAAG which allowed a separate counter to be used which was not the same depth as the service counter itself.  Like we explained above, these separate counters are difficult for persons with disabilities because they cannot easily community with the agent behind the taller counter.  That is why the 2010 ADA Standards requires that a lower counter which is the same depth as the main counter be provided.

276c8e11-ba2b-42e8-be9a-e5799e325a48

At the gate, sometimes the air carriers offer tables for people to use which they wait for their plane to board.  These would fall under ADA Section 902 as a non-employee work surface.  These should have a portion of the counter at 34″ a.f.f. maximum and have a knee space per section 306.

b2b75a11-f8f8-4ccd-baf6-21c64e276f15

If there are power outlets located at the counter, those should be within reach range.

871b804a-14dd-4ff9-b83c-5bbb04677267

Jet Bridge and Airplanes

At the terminal gate, passengers go through a door and enter the Jet bridge. This is essentially a movable piece of equipment which allows passenger to board the plane. This is technically not part of the airport and will not fall under the ADA. The requirements for the jet bridge, the slope, handrails etc. will be found in the ACAA. Same with the requirements for inside the airplane. People with disabilities do not enter the plane on their own. There are procedures that air carriers follow with all their passengers with disabilities.

5eb73519-0df7-4dc0-9698-a2e9bd1e4dc7

Upcoming CEU opportunities

Note: We will be closed on September 25 and 26

September 4- How to Make Interior Spaces Accessible TAID 1-3 p.m.

September 9- Procrastinator’s Day Barrier Free Seminar at AIA Dallas

November 6- Early Bird Three Hr Seminar: Applying TAS in Existing and Renovated Buildings” at the TSA Convention in Houston Texas

November 13- Half Moon Class 10:45 a.m.

November 13- CSI Dallas Meeting 7-8 p.m.

We are celebrating our 10th year of service to the building industry as a Registered Accessibility Specialist!  Mention this newsletter and receive 10% off your next review or inspection.

If you want to learn more about these standards, be sure to check out my books:

“The ADA Companion Guide”

“Applying the ADA” published by Wiley. 

They are available for sale now. (also available as an e-book)

If you have any questions about these or any other topics, please feel free to contact me anytime.

Marcela Abadi Rhoads, RAS #240
Abadi Accessibility
214. 403.8714
marhoads@abadiaccess.com
www.abadiaccess.com

Useful Links
4211966d-1763-427b-b22d-635a5a5536d8
 23e5e0af-7846-472b-b702-19386acb4fca0e98de4a-47d4-412d-9302-b0212a4b2b0d

Polling Places

Saturday, November 24th, 2012

There are just 5 days before we all get out and vote for President of the United States. Voting is a right that is protected for everyone who is eligible, including the disabled community. Polling places must be accessible. Even though they are temporary places, they are still a voting place and will require some form of access. The voter who is disabled must be able to have the same privacy as everyone else. The voter who is disabled must have access to the same ballot and the same method of voting as everyone else. So how does a polling place provide this access? The ADA website has a pamphlet that they put out in 2004 that explains how to provide access even when the polling place is only temporary. The Election Assistance Commission has a video that is also helpful for polling places to provide access. Below is a summary

Polling Places Accessibility requirements

A. Accessible parking or passenger drop off should be available

d278d02e-4641-4ede-8e85-edc1ba4322da

Passenger Drop Off

  1. Access aisle depth is at least 5′-0″
  2. Access aisle lenght is at least 20 feet
  3. Curb ramp connects access aisle to the accessible route to the accessible entrance of the polling places.

Parking

1bcc4557-4f91-4994-970e-7fbde6a64dde

 

  1. Marked access aisle
  2. no more than 2% slope for both parking and access aisle
  3. Parking sign
  4. Accessible route from parking up to the entrance of the polling place

B. An Accessible route to the entrance

eb72a97c-c0e1-41e9-ba1b-6215055638d8

Route must be unobstructed

C. An accessible entrance to the voting site (It can be a temporary ramp)

edde9397-bec6-42b9-a35e-06af776f6fea

Ramp

  1. At least 36″ between handrails
  2.  Top landing part of the walk
  3. Bottom landing part of walk
  4. Handrails height 34″ to 38″
  5. Edge Protection

D. A route free from hazards

cd8c09e7-d00c-4a0d-9307-0db98f5fde85

  1. Wall mounted drinking fountains are a hazard when the front projects more than 4″ beyond the wall and the bottom is more than 47″ above the floor
  2. Wall mounted objects cannot project more than 4 inches beyond the wall if the bottom is not in the cane-detectable area below 27 inches off the floor
  3. Overhead objects must be at least 80 inches off the floor

E. A route to the voting booth and to all the common spaces within the facilitya5d48364-45aa-4b80-b639-42e93a125aee

 

  1. Accessible route connects building entrance with the voting area, including voter check in and accessible voting machine
  2. Accessible route connects the accessible entrance with voting areas
  3. Accessible door and doorway to voting area,

Note: A turning space should also be provided. If there are deaf voters who need assistance, the blinds should be closed behind the check-in so voters who read lips can communicate with the voting staff.

F. Temporary Solutions for Election Day

d477fb13-c725-4aef-839a-946cae32d6c9

If a polling area is not accessible, find an accessible space near the voting area. Counter or table where the voting is taking place should be between 28 in to 34 inches in height and a forward approach knee space should be provided

Everyone should go to their polling places and make sure there are facilities that are accessible for voters in wheelchairs, voters who are visually impaired as well as hearing impaired. Let’s try and make this election an accessible one.

Continuing Education Opportunities

November 2- International Facilities Managers Association Convention in San Antonio, Texas

November 7- provided by SSTL Codes 4 hr ADA seminar in Tulsa OK

If you want to learn more about the new Standards, The ADA Companion Guide explains the 2004 ADAAG Guidelines  with commentary and explanations throughout.  The 2004 Guidelines were adopted by the DOJ to create the 2010 Standards and by Texas to create the 2012 TAS.  This book explains the technical requirements for both.

 If you have any questions about these or any other topics, please feel free to contact me anytime.
Marcela Abadi Rhoads, RAS #240
Abadi Accessibility
214. 403.8714

What is the deal with accessible swimming pools?

Sunday, June 24th, 2012

 ADA Section 242 Swimming Poools, Wading Pools and Spas
For swimming pools to be accessible they must have at least one accessible means of entry.  The ADA Standards allows the following methods of entry into a pool:
Pool Lifts
lift
lift
They must be located in an area shallower than 48″ deep.  If the entire pool is deeper than 48″ then location is not dictated and it can go anywhere.
Must be permanently installed.
Sloped Entry
pool
ramp 
 
They are just like ramps, but do not require slip resistant surface or handrail extensions.  They should only go as deep as 30″ below the water level.  If the pool is deeper, a platform at 30″ that is 5′-0″ wide should be provided.  The sloped entry does not extend beyond that.
Transfer Walls
 
 transfer walls
Transfer System 
 
transfer system 
Pools Stairs

 

 

 If the pool is larger than 300 linear feet of pool wall, then two means of entry should be provided.  At least one of the means of entry should be a lift or a sloped entry.

 

 Swimming facilities- Per US Access Board

Aquatic Recreation Facilities

  Wave action pools, leisure rivers, sand bottom pools, and other pools where access to the water is limited to one area and where everyone gets in and out at the same place, must provide at least one accessible means of entry, no matter how many linear feet of pool wall is provided. The accessible means of entry can be either a pool lift, sloped entry, or transfer system.

 

wave 

 

Catch Pools

A catch pool is a body of water where water slide flumes drop users into the water. An accessible means of entry or exit is not required into the catch pool. However, an accessible route must connect to the edge of the catch pool.

 

 flumes

 

 

Wading Pools
A wading pool is a pool designed for shallow depth and is used for wading. Each wading pool must provide at least one sloped entry into the deepest part. Other forms of entry may be provided as long as a sloped entry is provided. The sloped entries for wading pools are not required to have handrails.

 

Spas
Spas must provide at least one accessible means of entry, which can be a pool lift, transfer wall, or transfer system. If spas are provided in a cluster, 5 percent of the total-or at least one spa-must be accessible. If there is more than one cluster, one spa or 5 percent per cluster must be accessible.

 

spa  

 

Footrests are not required on pool lifts provided at spas. However, footrests or retractable leg supports are encouraged, especially on lifts used in larger spas, where the water depth is 34 inches or more and there is sufficient space.

 

  

 Department of Justice Requirements

Since swimming pools were not required to be accessible in the 1991 ADAAG, this brand new requirement applies to new construction that occurs after the mandatory date of March 15, 2012.  But the DOJ also required that existing facilities be brought up to compliance “as it is readily achievable”.  What this means is that means is that compliance should be achieved without much effort and expense.

For existing facilities with swimming pools, what this means is that the means of entry should be provided if there is enough money and if it does not cause undue burden for the building owner.  These terms are very subjective and they must be backed up with financial proof.  Many members of the hospitality industry were concerned about these new requirements, and therefore the DOJ gave an extension until January 31, 2013 to comply with these requirements.  My colleague Ken Otten wrote a great blog about it.  I recommend that you read it to gain a better understanding of this ruling.

Is the accessibility of your business good business?

Tuesday, June 12th, 2012

This guest blog is brought to you by my friend William J. Martin, WJM Architect (photo credit Mike Pollio).  I met William on Twitter and have been following his amazing work for over two years.  He is amazing and I’m grateful and flattered that he decided to write a blog post for our site.  Enjoy!

What prevents businesses from making the changes that make their businesses handicap accessible has many parts. Many business owners tell me it’s about money and construction cost — a big investment without any financial return.  I do understand that no one likes to spend money on things they don’t believe necessary to operate their business, but what if it turns out to be good business?

Sometimes events occur that help to illustrate the value of consulting with an accessibility design professional to bring your business into compliance with the  accessibility codes and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) requirements.

I recently had a project that involved ADA upgrades to a long established restaurant.  This particular project was not that much different than many of the other projects that I had designed in the past, with one exception…. It was severely damaged by fire and was over 140 years old.  It was damaged,  but not destroyed.  The beloved building would be repaired and rebuilt.

Whenever there is a fire in a building, it is a tragedy.  If the building is 140 years old and has a fire, it is a serious tragedy.  Buildings like that are vital to the heritage of their community.  Having something as permanent as a beloved local building damaged by fire can be extremely unsettling for many people.

My client called me the day after the fire and said “This building is 140 years old, we have been here for 40 years, we just had a severe fire.   You have to help me!”

After I saw the damage and got over my personal shock, I comforted the owners, “don’t worry,” I said, “the structural damage can be repaired.”  I then began to contemplate the task at hand.  My client would have loved to blink his eyes and have everything put back exactly as it was before the fire.  However, the extent of the damage was more than sufficient to require building code upgrades, including  accessibility upgrades.  The multilevel interior dining rooms would have to change.  Toilet facilities would have to be addressed.

After assisting in obtaining the cleanup and selective demolition permit, the very next thing I did was to prepare a comprehensive building code analysis to identify the exact upgrades that would be required based on the extent of the damage.  This had to be done first, since it affected the overall approach to the fire damage repair and rebuild design work.  I met with the building officials and had them review and sign off on the code analysis and required upgrades.  This way I had a clear and unchanging set of requirements specific to this project.  The full extent of required upgrades were established and I could now begin the redesign work.

With significant concern in his eyes my client said… ”I can’t lose paying customer tables and seats for ramps and toilets that I did not have before the fire.  You have to help me!  I assured him I would do the very best I could to resolve all issues and get the restaurant open as soon as possible.  His response was direct, “If it was so easy, don’t you think I would have made those handicap changes already.” [Note: we prefer the word accessible rather than handicap]

This was a normal reaction from a very savvy businessman assessing a difficult situation.  For an accessibility design professional , this was a design problem to be solved.

Armed with my ADA/ANSI code analysis, I began to look for solutions.  The dining rooms were 2 steps up and down from one another.   It seemed like there were steps everywhere.  The ladies toilet rooms were on the second floor, a full flight of stairs up from the dining rooms.  The mens toilet room was actually 2 small individual toilet rooms just off the dining room.  The 140 year old wood framed building had been a Victorian house, a hotel, rooming house, bar, and finally, most recently, the fire damaged restaurant.

Built right up to the street line, there was no front yard for any kind of ramp.

 

The main building had long ago been connected and combined with the buildings next door. These connected buildings were why every floor was at a different level.  They were built as separate buildings and combined later into the dining rooms, kitchen and bar of the restaurant.

The old connected storefront was previously converted into an emergency exit and alarmed to prevent casual use.  Even though there was a step to the doorway, the recess of the storefront allowed for a ramp to meet the sidewalk.  There was my new accessible entry.  The four steps up at the existing traditional entry could remain as I designed this entry adjacent to serve as a new ramped entry.  There were no tables allowed in front of this emergency exit, so no tables and chairs were affected by this change.

Next the dining room levels had to be addressed.  I could get a ramp in from outside, but now I had to find an accessible route within the space.  The 14 inch difference between floor levels meant a 14 foot long ramp in the dining rooms with landing space, railings, turning clearances, etc.  This would certainly affect tables and chairs in the dining rooms and this was what my client felt was devastating to his restaurant seat count.  I began to get a headache.

Since circulation space could also serve as ramp landing space, I analyzed the circulation around the tables and the kitchen area.  The kitchen was also 2 steps higher than the dining room.  The hallways connecting the dining rooms to the kitchen could not be used for tables regardless.

Instead of a single 14 foot long ramp, I designed two 7 foot ramp sections — one in each dining room using these existing hallways.  The two ramps met at a new mid level where I created a comfortable landing with proper turning radius.  Kitchen entry was shifted over slightly.  The fire had begun in the kitchen and this doorway move could be done easily during the kitchen redesign.

Adjacent to the new ramp landing  space was a large storage closet where beverages were dispensed and glasses stored.  I relocated the beverage function into the new efficient commercial kitchen design and used this closet space for a unisex accessible toilet room.

 

I aligned the toilet room floor at the new landing mid level, with the door to the toilet room opening off the ramp landing.  There was proper clearance for the ramps, turning, handrails, and the required toilet room door approach clearances.  The closet interior was slightly larger than was needed for the a compliant toilet room.

I now had the interior accessible route connecting the dining room levels and the required unisex handicap toilet room.  This was accomplished without displacing a single customer seat.

After I confirmed all of the many overlapping ADA clearance requirements, I grabbed my sketch and met with the owner to explain how it would work.  At first he could not believe it.  The ramps were much shorter than he was told would be necessary.  When I explained the new mid level between the two ramps, his eyes grew big as he realized that it was possible after all.

Nearly any building can be made accessible, it’s really a matter of architectural creativity and open minded problem solving.

The fire damaged restaurant, with the handicap accessibility changes, was completed and re-opened.  Like any beloved neighborhood business, the outpouring of public support resulted in increased business in the weeks and months since the re-opening.

 

 

I suggested to the owner that they include in their advertising a few words about the new  accessible features.  The result has been a sustained increase in their business. Able bodied people now bring disabled relatives to eat.  More elderly patrons, many with only minor mobility issues, now flock in groups to enjoy the best burgers around.  Some people come just to see the inside of the 140 year old building.  They never thought they would be able move freely between the levels and now they come just because they can.

In the end my client told me the changes that were made, made good business sense.  People who had difficulty entering the restaurant because of the front steps now come to dine and bring with them their families and friends AND their dollars…

Accessibility professionals know that making your business  accessible isn’t just part of the building code, it’s good for your business.

Over the years I have assisted businesses and witnessed them benefit substantially from handicap accessible modifications made to their buildings, especially service businesses.

Accessibility for all is good business.

 

Accessible Pools

Wednesday, May 23rd, 2012

The 2010 ADA Standards require that swimming pools, wading pools and spas be made accessible to the disabled community.  Existing pools also have to comply , but the Department of Justice allows that to happen “as it is readily achievable”. This newsletter explains what the requirements are and what the deadlines to comply will be.

ADA Section 242 Swimming Poools, Wading Pools and Spas

For swimming pools to be accessible they must have at least one accessible means of entry.  The ADA Standards allows the following methods of entry into a pool:

Pool Lifts

da3436ee-affa-4407-8129-013d5c422f45

8f357722-5292-4de7-800f-3b274f69274e

They are not required if the pool is deeper than 48″
Must be permanently installed.

Sloped Entry
e8fada3c-f48a-498a-ba2d-dac5e7850703
f2ce497b-8c78-4f8b-9068-021c99f18d1f
They are just like ramps, but do not require slip resistant surface or handrail extensions.

Transfer Walls
f764ff36-293e-4380-98da-e91819069643
Transfer System 
5b725f60-2e11-4c33-a1a3-3936ce7dcc8a
Pools Stairs
6107819c-1e45-4050-9545-3581897432e3
If the pool is larger than 300 linear feet of pool wall, then two means of entry should be provided. At least one of the means of entry should be a lift or a sloped entry.

Swimming facilities- Per US Access Board

Aquatic Recreation Facilities

Wave action pools, leisure rivers, sand bottom pools, and other pools where access to the water is limited to one area and where everyone gets in and out at the same place, must provide at least one accessible means of entry, no matter how many linear feet of pool wall is provided. The accessible means of entry can be either a pool lift, sloped entry, or transfer system.

a60e5f31-f6ba-4e8f-947c-16f56263e150

Catch Pools
A catch pool is a body of water where water slide flumes drop users into the water. An accessible means of entry or exit is not required into the catch pool. However, an accessible route must connect to the edge of the catch pool.

81ba3a10-0131-4f9a-a7ec-5bc726808bd5

Wading Pools
A wading pool is a pool designed for shallow depth and is used for wading. Each wading pool must provide at least one sloped entry into the deepest part. Other forms of entry may be provided as long as a sloped entry is provided. The sloped entries for wading pools are not required to have handrails.

Spas
Spas must provide at least one accessible means of entry, which can be a pool lift, transfer wall, or transfer system. If spas are provided in a cluster, 5 percent of the total-or at least one spa-must be accessible. If there is more than one cluster, one spa or 5 percent per cluster must be accessible.

c7920ad3-d9f6-49b9-80cd-4f03bfec3140

Footrests are not required on pool lifts provided at spas. However, footrests or retractable leg supports are encouraged, especially on lifts used in larger spas, where the water depth is 34 inches or more and there is sufficient space.

Department of Justice Requirements

Since swimming pools were not required to be accessible in the 1991 ADAAG, this brand new requirement applies to new construction that occurs after the mandatory date of March 15, 2012.  But the DOJ also required that existing facilities be brought up to compliance “as it is readily achievable”.  What this means is that means is that compliance should be achieved without much effort and expense.

For existing facilities with swimming pools, what this means is that the means of entry should be provided if there is enough money and if it does not cause undue burden for the building owner.  These terms are very subjective and they must be backed up with financial proof.  Many members of the hospitality industry were concerned about these new requirements, and therefore the DOJ gave an extension until May 15th to comply with these requirements.  My colleague Ken Otten wrote a great blog about it.  I recommend that you read it to gain a better understanding of this ruling.

What’s next….

Continuing Education:

May 2nd: DOJ will be having a free webinar explaining swimming pools.  Register here

May 11th: AIA Knowledge Communities will have part 2 of the three part webinar about Universal Design.  Space is limited, so sign up here

If you want to learn more about the new Standards, The ADA Companion Guide explains the 2004 ADAAG Guidelines  with commentary and explanations throughout.  The 2004 Guidelines were adopted by the DOJ to create the 2010 Standards and by Texas to create the 2012 TAS.  This book explains the technical requirements for both.

If you have any questions about these or any other topics, please feel free to contact me anytime.

Marcela Abadi Rhoads, RAS #240

Abadi Accessibility
214. 403.8714